dr spock

Acid reflux Acne ADD/ ADHD Allergies Arthritis Asthma Autism Back pain Baldness
Bone loss Cancer Candida / Yeast Cold / Flu Chronic fatigue Cough Depression Diabetes Diarrhea
Eczema Fever Gout Gallstones Headache Hemmorrhoids High blood Insomnia Kidney failure
Migraine Radiation Sea sickness Sinus Sore throat Ulcers Active links bold and underlined

Macrobiotics
Macrobiotics as a natural cancer cure
What is macrobiotics?
Macrobiotics with Herman Aihara (16)
Macrobiotic diet
Principles of a macrobiotic diet
Cooked vs raw
Whole grains
Miso soup
Vegetables
Beans
Soy beans
Cooking oils
Sea salt
Sea vegetables
Pickles
Food supplements

Kushi on supplements
Macrobiotic diet for candida infection
Home Remedies & Natural Cures
Caprylic acid
Hyperbaric oxygen
Kuzu starch
Macrobiotic carp soup
Natural antibiotics
Neurofeedback
Probiotics
Qigong therapy
Sweet vegetable drink
Umeboshi
Fats & Oils
Why saturated fats are not harmful... but healthy
Why cholesterol is not harmful... but healthy
Harm of polyunsaturateds
Monounsaturated fats
Canola oil and its dangers
What are trans fats and why are they bad
Causes of heart diease
Recovery stories

How Dr Spock lived to 90

Melanoma recovery by Thomas Marron
Linda McGrath - Set free from bulimia
Health commentaries
Hydroponic vegetables -- are they safe?
Frankenfoods!
Phytonutrients in vegetables and fruits
Obesity among Malays
A sugar 'research'

Cough medicine

robert mendelsohnIf your doctor's cough medicine does not seem to work, here is a possible explanation from the book, Confessions of a Medical Heretic, by the late Dr Robert S Mendelsohn.

Dr Robert S Mendelsohn tells how the strategy behind cough mixtures can be quite puzzling:

  • There are two main types of cough medicine: expectorants that thin out mucus secretions so that they can be more easily expelled, and anti-ussives that suppress coughing. Many brands of cough mixtures contain both drugs. So you end up taking a drug to expel phlegm and another drug to suppress coughing so that the phlegm won't be expelled.

  • When a person has both a cough and a cold (runny nose) - and many people do when they have the flu - the prescription gets even more irrational. That person will probably be given an antihistamine – even though antihistamines are for allergies and are not effective against colds. But antihistamine thickens the mucus secretions. So they act against expectorants (in cough mixtures) which are supposed to thin out mucus.





Hmmm.... all of you should read Dr Robeert S Mendelsohn's book. It is an excellent expose how illogical and unscientific - stupid - the "scientific" world of modern medicine often is. But I deviate. Back to cough medicine...

Actually, the best "medicine" for cough cannot be found in a pill, syrup or cough drop. It is...


Rest and sleep

I came to this realisation around 1996. My sister was having a bad cough at that time. I was in the midst of launching an audiophile hifi business and was taking part in a hifi show. So for about a week, I worked extremely hard from early morning till late at night.

When the show ended, I developed a cough. It sounded exactly like my sister's. And it dawned on me that I was not really sick, but just very tired. So was my sister.

One of difficulties with using sleep and rest as a natural "cough medicine", unfortunately, is that coughing often prevents us from getting adequate sleep and rest. It can lead to insomnia or interrupted sleep. So we still need to find a way out of this situation.


Lotus root tea

The one natural cough medicine that I find most effective so far is lotus root tea. The lotus root, with its holes inside, is said in traditional Chinese medicine to resemble the lungs. It has similar energy to the lungs and is used to strengthen or tonify the lungs. For example, regularly taking a soup brewed with lotus root, peanuts and pork ribs is reputedly good for the lungs.

A simple macrobiotic remedy to remove mucus and phelgm is lotus root tea:

  1. Take one section lotus root, washed and scrubbed but do not peel off the skin. Grate the root and squeeze out the juice.
  2. Add equal amount water, eg 1/2 cup juice with 1/2 cup water.
  3. Add one pinch sea salt
  4. Bring to the boil and simmer 5 minutes
  5. Add a few drops ginger juice, squeezed from grated ginger.

This natural cough medicine is good for coughs and clearing phelgm, as well as for generally removing mucus from the body and strengthening the lungs.

Macrobiotic and natural food stores sell a powdered lotus root tea and all you need to do is add water and boil for a few minutes. But while the fresh lotus root tea is delicious, the powdered version takes some getting used to.


Black soybean tea

Another macrobiotic natural cough medicine, good for dry coughs, is black soybean tea. I remember this was served at the "medical center" when I attended the Kushi Institute Macrobiotic Summer Camp in 1993.

Note: black soy beans are different from black turtle beans, although they look similar. They have different qualities and I don't think the black turtle beans work as a cough remedy. Make sure you buy the right type.

  1. Boil together: one cup black soybeans / 2-inch strip kombu seaweed, finely chopped / four cups water
  2. Reduce the flame to low and simmer for about 45 minutes,
  3. Strain and drink the liquid.
  4. You may continue to cook the beans and eat them in a separate dish.


Chinese pears with sweet and bitter almonds

Talkiing about natural cough medicine being delicious, here is one so good you can eat it as a dessert even if you don't have a cough. The main ingredients are Chinese pears and almonds, both of which are different from their Western counterparts.

chinese pearChinese and Japanese pears are round or oval, not pear-shaped and they come with yellow, light brown or light green skins. The flesh is crunchy. There are several varieties, including ya li (Chinese) and hosui (Japanese).

Chinese almonds are actually apricot kernels, much smaller and flatter, as well as more triangluar than regular almonds. Two types, Northern bitter almonds and Southern sweet almonds, are often sold mixed together in Chinese herbal and dried foods stores.

Apricot kernels have medicinal properties. They contain the rare Vitamin B17 or laetrile, which is claimed, but not scientifically proven, to be a cancer cure. But they must always be taken cooked (boiled or roasted) and in small quantities, generally not more than 20 a day, as they contain cynaide, which is toxic. For occasional medicinal use, slightly more is okay.

This delicious natural cough medicine can also be eaten as a dessert. You need:

  • chinese almondsFour Chinese pears - peel, cut into quarters, remove the seeds and soak in salted water to prevent them from turning brown due to oxidation.
  • 3 tablespoons of sweet and bitter almonds
  • 6 to 8 cups of water
  • 2 pieces, or about 80 to 100 grams, rock sugar (This is sugar that come in large chunks like rocks).

Put all the ingredients into a pot, bring to a boil and simmer for at least an hour, or up to several hours if you like. Add more water if necessary when you cook for a long time. Enjoy!


Bird's nest

Still on the subject of delicious natural cough medicine, I should mention bird's nest. This is the dried saliva of a species of small swift (or swiftlet) use the build its nest. It is harvested mainly in Southeast Asia, including Thailand and Borneo or Kalimantan in Indonesia.

This is not so much a cough medicine that brings instant relief, but more of a lung tonic for a long-term cure. Regular consumption over a period will strengthen a person's lungs and so this is particularly helpful for those with chronic cough, or those who develop the cough easily.

Bird's nest is extremely expensive. Ready-brewed bird's nest drink costs tens of dollars for a tiny bottle that is basically one guip or two or three small sips.

Uncooked bird's nest vary greatly in price, depending on the quality. Some of the most expensive is called blood nest and can cost hundreds of dollars for a few grams, enough to make a bowl of bird's nest soup. Note, however, that some of the cheaper may be adulterated or even fakes, or may have been treated with bleach and other chemicals that you would not want to put into your body. Always buy bird's nest from reputable dealers.


Off the shelf cough syrups

There are many natural cough remedies, as well as some "unnatural" remedies that are sold as over the counter cough medicine. There are too many to discuss here, but as I researched for this article, I found a few surprises that I would like to share:

  • Woods Great Peppermint Cure: This was the cough medicine I grew up with and I always thought it was a natural cough remedy made from Peppermint. How wrong I was! The main ingredient is guaifenesin. Although similar medicines were derived from the guaiac tree - and used by Native Americans for hundreds of years - guaifenesin is classified as a drug. I guess this means it is the purified, refined version that is somewhat different from the original thing. Anyway, I stopped taking Woods when I found out it contains the artificial sweetner, aspartame.

  • Likewise, a lot of cough drops, including supposedly "natural" brands are nowadays made with aspartame. I discovered, for example, that the Asian version of the Swiss herbal candy, Ricola contain aspartame while the European version apparently does not. Since they are not all that effective to begin with, I've stopped taking them.


Chinese cough medicine

For ready-made natural cough remedies, I have developed greater confidence in Chinese cough syrups. This is not because I am Chinese. In fact, I have an English education and a more Western outlook in life. But after I discovered natural health in 1985, I started to explore traditional Chinese medicine and I find that it makes a lot of sense.

Many Chinese cough medicines are made either from Chinese red dates or jujubes or from loquats.

Jujube is a small hard fruit about 1.5 to 3 cm long, with the taste and consistency of an apple. Strictly speaking it is not a date, unlike regular dates that grow from date palms in the desert. Instead, the jujube or Chinese red date is from a small shrub that grows extensively, in China, Korea, Vietnam, India, East Asia and Europe.

In the US and Canada, jujube may simply refer to any soft, gummy candy. But there is actually a type of cough candy called "jujubes" that I used to be given when I was young. Again, I stopped eating this when I found out it contains aspartame!

Jujube is also popular in Korea where, besides being a cough remedy, it is reputed to be a stress reliever. In Australia, there is a jujube-based drink called 1-bil, which the manufacturer recommends "when you feel yourself becoming distressed."

Loquat is a bit harder to describe. It is a small yellow / orange fruit, about 3 to 5 cm in diameter, with smooth fine hair on its skin. The orange flesh is succulent, like a cross between a peach and an orange. In terms of botanical classification, it is said to be a distant relative of the apple. But that is misleading because its taste and texture are quite different compared to apples.

Loquats blends well with other fruits and make good fruit cocktails. But before this begin to read like a desserts website, l should note that loquats syrups are very widely used by the Chinese as natural cough remedies. The Chinese name, pipa gao, meaning "loquat paste" is almost synonymous with cough medicine.

There are a number of loquat-based natural cough medicine, of which the best known must surely be King-to Nin Jiom Pei Pa Koa. It is one of the few Chinese cough rmedicine that have been scientifically studied. In 1994, a study at the China Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine reported that Pharmacological studies of nin jiom pei pa koa indicated it had significant effect on relieving coughs, removing sputum, relieving asthma in vivo and in vitro.

This cough medicine is actually quite a complex blend of herbal ingredients. Apart from loquat and loquat leaves, other ingredients include bitter apricot kernels, ginger, licorice, etc. The base is syrup and honey.

Nin Jiom Pei Pa Koa used to be one of my favourite natural cough remedies, until one day my Chinese physician introduced me to something better. This is also one of the loquat-based cough medicine, and its English name is Honey-condensed Loquat Extract with Bird's Nest, Cordycep, Sinensis and Fritillaria Verticillata.

cough syrupWhat a mouthful of a name! Apart from Bird's nest, cordycep is another expensive ingredient, costing a few hundred dollars for one tahil (a Chinese measure equals to 37.8 grams). So don't expect a lot of these two ingredients in there. A 300 ml bottle contains just 0.36 grams of each.

Whether because of these ingredients, or other reasons, this is the most effective natural cough medicine that I have tried so far. Unfortunately, is not as commonly available, even in Singapore, as Nin Jiom Pei Pa Koa. But it is just as inexpensive, at about S$7 a bottle. If you have a cough, look for it!

And if your cough persists, then obviously home-made or ready-bought cough medicine - or your knowledge about how to use them - aren't good enough.

Coughs can be difficult to self-medicate because there are many different types of coughs. In Western medicine, a difference is made between productive coughs - which expel phelgm - and unproductive coughs which don't. In Chinese medicine, coughs are classified according to whether they are heaty or cooling, dry or damp, etc.

The other difficulty with self-medication is that what the cough patient really needs is plenty of rest and sleep.

So if your cough persists, seek professional help such as traditional Chinese medicine physicians - I have had very good experiences with them - or homeopaths. Regular doctors, with their regular cough mixtures, are not going to be of great help.

In the meantime, you can check out more cough medicine on my page about sore throat cures, since most sore thorat remedies are effective for coughs as well.